US: 'No Way' to Ensure Israeli Security Without Palestinian State

Improve the News Foundation -

Facts

  • Seemingly in response to comments by Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu, US Dept. of State spokesperson Matthew Miller said on Thursday that 'no way' exists to solve Israel's long-term security concerns and the short-term challenges of rebuilding Gaza without the establishment of a Palestinian state. Despite reportedly growing disagreements between Israel and the US, he said that US support is 'ironclad' and the US was merely 'laying out for them the opportunity that they have.'1
  • Disagreements regarding Israel's plans for Gaza after the war have expanded recently, with a member of the country's war cabinet, former army chief Gadi Eisenkot, saying late on Thursday that only a ceasefire deal would facilitate the release of Israeli hostages. Netanyahu has repeatedly said that the war will continue until Hamas has been destroyed and avoided discussions of Gaza's post-war governance.2
  • Meanwhile, EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell also said on Friday that the only peaceful solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict included the establishment of a Palestinian state, something he said may need to be 'imposed from the outside.'3
  • In Gaza, Jordan accused Israel of deliberately targeting its newest field hospital in Khan Younis on Wednesday, allegedly blocking the entrance with a tank and shooting at the facility. Israel denied that it had attacked the field hospital, saying it was engaged in a gunfight with Hamas fighters nearby.4
  • Also, Russia's Foreign Ministry said on Friday that it had received a delegation of Hamas officials in Moscow to discuss efforts to end the war, address the humanitarian crisis, and release the hostages. Hamas is currently holding three Russian nationals. The Russian Foreign Ministry stated that the Kremlin supported a full Middle East solution based on UN Security Council deliberations.5
  • Gaza's health ministry reports that the conflict has killed nearly 25K people in the Gaza Strip, the majority of whom were women and children. The war has also created a rapidly deteriorating humanitarian situation. The official Israeli death toll on Oct. 7 stands at around 1.2K people (and there are still over 100 hostages being held in the Gaza Strip).6

Sources: 1Reuters, 2Associated Press, 3The Times of Israel, 4NPR Online News, 5The Jerusalem Post and 6The Guardian.

Narratives

  • Pro-establishment narrative, as provided by POLITICO. The US is doing everything it can to both ensure that Israel can eliminate Hamas's military capabilities and prevent regional escalation. Israel must be able to defend itself from terrorist attacks, whether from Gaza or elsewhere, and is taking the right steps to wind down its military operations in Gaza, as it is not in the US or Israel's best interest to see the conflict escalate. Nevertheless, the US is prepared to defend its allies in the region and deter threats to regional and global security.
  • Pro-Israel narrative, as provided by The Jerusalem Post. Though this has been a tragic war, Israel must eliminate Hamas and restore deterrence with Iran and its proxy Hezbollah. Hezbollah is a terrorist army with far greater military capabilities than Hamas, and Israel cannot allow its citizens residing in the north to live under the constant threat of terrorist attacks. The UN resolution that ended the 2006 war with Hezbollah has failed to ensure Israel's security, and if some sort of new arrangement is not made, Israel will be forced to intervene. Likewise, in Gaza, Hamas's military capabilities must be eliminated to ensure Israel's security.
  • Pro-Palestine narrative, as provided by Middle East Eye. Israel continues to demonstrate that its war is not against Hamas or Hezbollah but against the Palestinian and Lebanese people as a whole. Nowhere in Gaza is safe, and Israel has effectively rendered large swaths of the strip uninhabitable. Israel is killing Palestinians at an unprecedented rate and has transformed Gaza into a wasteland. Though the US, Israel's biggest ally, wants to minimize the war's intensity, it must instead exert more pressure to end the war completely.

Predictions