SCOTUS Signals Support for Tennessee Ban on Trans Treatments for Minors
The US Supreme Court (SCOTUS) heard oral arguments on Wednesday over Tennessee's ban on transgender treatments for minors, with the court's six-conservative-justice-majority appearing skeptical of challenges to the law....
0:00
/1861
Facts
- The US Supreme Court (SCOTUS) heard oral arguments on Wednesday over Tennessee's ban on transgender treatments for minors, with the court's six-conservative-justice-majority appearing skeptical of challenges to the law.[1][2]
- The case centers on whether Tennessee's law violates the Constitution's equal protection guarantee by banning treatments like puberty blockers and hormone therapy for transgender youth while allowing the same medications for other medical purposes.[3][4][5]
- Arguing against the ban was Chase Strangio, who became the first openly transgender attorney to argue before SCOTUS, representing families and the Biden administration.[5][6]
- Conservative Chief Justice John Roberts suggested the issue should be left to state legislatures rather than courts, while liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor expressed her opposition to Tennesee's law.[7][8]
- The case could affect similar laws in more than 20 other states that have enacted restrictions on transgender treatments for minors.[9][8]
- The court's ruling, expected by June 2025, will likely also influence future cases, including bathroom access and sports participation.[1][7]
Sources: [1]New York Post, [2]Guardian, [3]The Telegraph, [4]CNN, [5]NBC, [6]Townhall, [7]FOX News, [8]New York Times and [9]Forbes.
Narratives
- Right narrative, as provided by New York Post and The Telegraph. SCOTUS must uphold Tennessee’s law to protect children from irreversible medical procedures based on weak evidence. Puberty blockers and surgeries do not help children but rather cause lasting harm, including infertility and regret. European nations are adopting caution on the issue, while US practices are prioritizing ideology over science. Protecting minors requires prioritizing their long-term welfare.
- Left narrative, as provided by MSNBC and GLAAD. Tennessee's ban on gender-affirming care for young trans kids is inhumane and poses a national threat to children's rights. Denying medically necessary care forces trans youth to endure distressing and irreversible changes, while criminalizing providers undermines essential health care. Upholding this law could set a dangerous precedent, empowering further restrictions on personal medical decisions for all Americans.
