UK: Starmer Refuses to Rule Out Future Tax Raises

Improve the News Foundation -
0:00
/1861

Facts

  • UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer has indicated that he cannot rule out future tax increases, despite Chancellor Rachel Reeves previously stating that she is 'not coming back with more borrowing or more taxes.'[1]
  • Starmer stated that while tax rises were not planned, the Prime Minister couldn't rule out 'circumstances unforeseen in the future that wouldn't lead to any change at all.'[2][3]
  • Starmer cited events such as the COVID pandemic and the ongoing conflict in Ukraine as examples of world events that previously led to tax increases.[4][5]
  • When previously asked about Reeves's comments in the House of Commons last month, Starmer stated that he was 'not going to write the next five years of Budgets.'[6]
  • In October, Reeves raised taxes by approximately £40B ($50B), including £25B ($32B) from employer National Insurance contributions as well as increases to capital gains tax and inheritance tax.[7][8]
  • As of Dec. 2 YouGov found UK government disapproval to sit at 58% compared to 22% approval, while a recent poll by Find Out Now showed Labour third (23%) behind Reform UK (24%), and the Conservatives (26%).[9][10]

Sources: [1]BBC News, [2]Express.co.uk, [3]The Guardian, [4]Sky News, [5]The Times, [6]Parliament, [7]The Telegraph, [8]The Mirror, [9]foundoutnow.co.uk and [10]Yougov.

Narratives

  • Left narrative, as provided by Guardian and The Mirror. Barring an unexpected disaster, tax raises were a necessary one-off approach to restoring stability and addressing long-term challenges. Reeves' commitment to fixing the 'black hole' in public finances, while sparing working people from further tax burdens, shows decisive leadership. Businesses may face short-term pain, but her emphasis on funding vital public services like the National Health Service and education lays the groundwork for sustainable growth.
  • Right narrative, as provided by The Telegraph and Daily Mail. Labour's wavering on tax promises underscores a troubling lack of clarity in its fiscal strategy. Despite Rachel Reeves' earlier assurance against further tax hikes, Keir Starmer's refusal to rule them out fuels skepticism about Labour’s economic credibility. This inconsistency risks further eroding public trust and heightening business uncertainty — which is already strained by the recent national insurance hike.

Predictions