Kenya: Man Sentenced to Prison for Murder of LGBTQ+ Activist

Improve the News Foundation -

Facts

  • In Kenya, Jacktone Odhiambo, a 25-year-old photographer, received a 50-year prison sentence for murdering LGBTQ+ activist Edwin Chiloba, whose body was found in a metal box near Eldoret in January 2023.[1][2]
  • DNA evidence confirmed an intimate relationship between the two men, who were housemates living near the University of Eldoret where Chiloba was a student.[2][3][4]
  • Over the course of the trial, the court heard testimony from 23 witnesses, including forensic evidence that showed Chiloba died from asphyxiation caused by smothering, with socks stuffed into his mouth.[2][5]
  • Judge Reuben Nyakundi determined that Odhiambo had planned the murder, waiting until they returned from a nightclub, and showed no remorse for the killing.[2][4]
  • The prosecution presented evidence that Odhiambo spent Chiloba's money after the murder, though the court made no definitive finding about the motive for the killing.[3][6]
  • Chiloba was a 25-year-old fashion designer and prominent LGBTQ+ activist known for fighting discrimination in Kenya, where same-sex relationships remain illegal. The case drew international attention to LGBTQ+ rights in Kenya, which Pres. William Ruto has called a "non-issue."[3][4]

Sources: [1]Washington Post, [2]BBC News, [3]The Pink News, [4]The Guardian, [5]DW and [6]The New York Times.

Narratives

  • Narrative A, as provided by DW and The Pinnacle Gazette. This is a deeply tragic case, but the verdict represents a significant milestone for justice and equality in Kenya, demonstrating that the legal system can protect all citizens regardless of identity. The thorough investigation and substantial sentence send a strong message about the severity of hate-motivated crimes and the need to protect vulnerable communities.
  • Narrative B, as provided by Washington Post, The Guardian and Africa News. This case unnecessarily politicizes a personal dispute between housemates and draws unwarranted attention to private matters. Police have ruled out hate crimes in this case, which should be treated like any other murder investigation.