Judge Rules Ga. Congressional Map is Illegal

Facts

  • US District Court Judge Steve C. Jones on Thursday ordered Georgia's congressional map to be redrawn by its state legislature after finding that its current boundaries discriminate against Black voters.1
  • In addition, Jones is requiring the state to draw two new Black-majority districts in the state's 56-seat state Senate and five new Black-majority districts in the 180-seat state House.2
  • Within the 516-page ruling, Jones wrote that despite 'great strides' in the state, Georgia's political process was still not 'equally open to Black voters' — ruling the current map violates the 1965 Voting Rights Act.3
  • Georgia Republican Gov. Brian Kemp has arranged for a Nov. 29 special legislative session to re-examine the maps. Jones, an appointee of former Pres. Barack Obama, has set a Dec. 8 deadline for redrawing the boundaries.4
  • GOP state lawmakers last redrew the congressional map in 2021. Recent court rulings in Alabama and Florida also concluded Republican legislatures had unfairly reduced the voting ability of Black residents.5
  • A spokesperson for state Attorney General Chris Carr said his office is “analyzing all legal options” while deciding whether to appeal.6

Sources: 1Politico, 2Associated Press, 3Reuters, 4NPR Online News, 5CBS and 6NBC.

Narratives

  • Republican narrative, as provided by FOX News. There remains a chance this decision will be overturned, and Georgia’s legislators shouldn’t redraw any maps until every legal option has been exhausted. The Obama-nominated judge is simply trying to sway the balance of power in Congress.
  • Democratic narrative, as provided by The Atlanta Voice. The decision is a win for democracy and those who stand against voter suppression. Republicans intentionally drew maps that failed to reflect the state's demographics. There’s hope that in the near future, it won’t take the courts to fight this type of racism.