Harvard Board Says President Won't Lose Job Over Congress Appearance

Improve the News Foundation -
0:00
/1861

Facts

  • Harvard University's 13-member school board has announced its continued support for President Claudine Gay following comments made during a congressional appearance last week that focused on allegations of recent and rising antisemitism on college campuses.1
  • The Harvard Corporation claimed that Gay remained the 'right leader to help our community heal,' claiming that the university president had 'apologized for how she handled her congressional testimony' and was 'committed to redoubling' efforts against antisemitism.2
  • During a Dec. 5 hearing held by the House Committee on Education, Gay stated that the calling for a 'genocide of Jews' depended 'on the context' for violating Harvard's bullying and harassment policies. Gay further specified that behavior that 'crosses into... bullying harassment, [and] intimidation' led to 'actionable conduct' by the university.3
  • A day later, Harvard released a statement from Gay on social media platform X, formerly known as Twitter, clarifying that rhetoric about violence or genocide against Jewish communities or any group was 'vile,' had no place at the university, and would be treated as a serious incident.4
  • Over 700 Harvard faculty members consequently signed a letter sent to the Harvard Corporation on Dec. 10 asking for the board to 'resist political pressures at odds with Harvard's commitment to academic freedom,' claiming Gay's continuation in the role was 'critical' to 'defending a culture of free inquiry.'5
  • The news comes as the now-former president of the University of Pennsylvania, Liz Magill, resigned for her own comments on the subject during the same committee hearing, alongside the chairman of the University's school board of trustees, Scott Bok.6

Sources: 1BBC News, 2Harvard university, 3NPR Online News, 4Forbes, 5The harvard crimson and 6Associated Press.

Narratives

  • Narrative A, as provided by New York Post. Harvard's defense of Gay's disgraceful comments is hypocritical considering the university's struggles with allowing free speech that it disagrees with on campus. While it's possible that Gay does wish to push back on antisemitism now that the issue has been raised, it seems more likely that any promises of protecting its Jewish community are a cynical move that doesn't address the oppressive ideologies that are pervasive in American college campuses. Harvard has deep work to do to protect the Jewish community and reject the knee-jerk cancelation of free speech alike.
  • Narrative B, as provided by The harvard crimson. While antisemitism, like many other forms of hate, is a problem within Harvard and America that must be solved, it's disingenuous for Congress to reshape the reality of campus life at the university. Gay's comments were a specific response in relation to Harvard's codified policies concerning harassment and bullying. Harvard's diverse academics — including scholars of religion and the Middle East — backed this move. The University is dedicated to being a safe space for its entire community.

Predictions