Democrats Seek a Classified Briefing on Whether House Chaos Helps China

Facts

  • In a letter shared with NBC News, a group of US House Democrats have written to National Intelligence Director Avril Haines and CIA Director William Burns alleging that China is using current legislative stagnation in Congress as a propaganda instrument.1
  • The letter, signed by the 11 minority members of the House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), requests a 'classified briefing' on how the CCP and 'foreign adversaries' were 'leveraging current political dysfunction' in the House of Representatives.1
  • The letter also states that they are 'deeply concerned' that the fallout from the current lack of a House Speaker could 'sow doubt' concerning the 'strength of the United States.'2
  • The letter continues, stating there are 'no assurances' that a federal government shutdown would be avoided on Nov. 17 — with the House approaching its third week without an elected speaker. The letter requests a 'classified intelligence briefing' by Oct. 31.1
  • This comes as Republicans are holding a vote Monday concerning nine new party candidates for the role of speaker. Republicans hold a 221-212 majority in the House, with 217 needed to elect a speaker.3
  • Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) was forcibly removed from the role of speaker early this month — the first time in history such a feat has occurred. So far, two Republican nominees — Steve Scalise (R-La.), and Jim Jordan (R-Ohio.) have failed in their bids for the role.4

Sources: 1NBC, 2The Hill, 3Reuters and 4NPR Online News.

Narratives

  • Democratic narrative, as provided by Los Angeles Times. GOP internal bickering merely highlights the general public's lack of trust in American institutions. This goes far beyond domestic politics, as the chaos in Congress is posing national security issues for the US which adversaries such as China are delighted to weaponize as propaganda. The Republican Party must fix its internal issues for the sake of the US at home and on the world stage.
  • Republican narrative, as provided by National Review. The GOP must now come together to reunite the House. If not, the House must consider allowing the speaker pro tempore to exercise greater power than we have currently witnessed. Either way, the Republican Party has the resolve to end this impasse and balance the ill-conceived policies of the Biden administration — including Biden's policies that are weak on China.
  • Pro-China narrative, as provided by China Daily. The lack of consensus and abundance of chaos in the US House of Representatives has exposed the continued divisions that have forever existed within American society. The US House statement is an inflection point and potential doomsday moment for American hegemony.

Predictions