CIA Warns Staff About Social Media Use After Official Shares Pro-Palestine Post

Improve the News Foundation -

Facts

  • The US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) on Tuesday sent out an internal email to employees cautioning them against making political statements on social media. This came after a report in the Financial Times made known that a high-ranking CIA official posted a pro-Palestine image on Facebook in the weeks following the Hamas attacks on Israel on Oct. 7.1
  • According to reporting from the Financial Times, the CIA official is the agency's associate deputy director for analysis. She is said to have changed her Facebook cover photo on Oct. 21 to an image of a man waving a Palestinian flag; an image that's frequently used to criticize Israel, the publication reported. 'The Financial Times has decided not to name her after the intelligence agency expressed concern about her safety,' it further said.2
  • Nonetheless, the FT further reported that she previously posted a selfie with 'Free Palestine' superimposed on the image — though the post is understood to be several years old. She also made posts criticizing antisemitism. 'Posting an overtly political image on a public platform is a very unusual move for a senior intelligence official,' the publication stated.2
  • A source with familiarity of the situation told the FT: 'The officer is a career analyst with extensive background in all aspects of the Middle East and this post [of the Palestinian flag] was not intended to express a position on the conflict.' The official previously oversaw the production of the President’s Daily Brief and is jointly responsible for managing all analysis distributed within the CIA, the FT further reported.3
  • Soon after, the CIA official was identified [by a number of media organizations including the Daily Caller and the Washington Free Beacon] as Amy McFadden. According to her LinkedIn page, she reportedly has worked at the CIA since 1999 and has since held a number of leadership positions. The profile further states: 'McFadden is the recipient of several prestigious IC [Intelligence Community] awards, including the Intelligence Medal of Merit, the CIA Director’s Award, and the George H.W. Bush Award for Excellence in Counterterrorism.4
  • According to a US official, McFadden was not disciplined in the wake of the news report. The official added that the email that went out to CIA employees was 'simply a reminder of existing policy.' In a statement, a CIA spokesperson said: 'CIA officers are committed to analytic objectivity, which is at the core of what we do as an Agency. CIA officers may have personal views, but this does not lessen their — or CIA’s — commitment to unbiased analysis.'1

Sources: 1NBC, 2The Financial Times, 3Daily Caller and 4Washington Free Beacon.

Narratives

  • Pro-establishment narrative, as provided by The Financial Times. CIA officials are committed to analytic objectivity in their work. Officers may have personal views but are still committed to unbiasedness as an organizational value. Nonetheless, this was a foolish move from a career official who knows better than to post on a divisive issue, particularly in the middle of a crisis.
  • Establishment-critical narrative, as provided by The Intercept. In aiding and abetting Israeli attacks on Gaza, which UN officials have already warned may breach international law, the US may be just as legally culpable if they provide direct military support. Some argue those crimes reach the threshold of genocide and/or genocidal intent. Given the intensity of bombing in Gaza, it's no wonder a growing number of US officials are growing uncomfortable.

Predictions