Australia: Labor's Pro-Palestine Senator Resigns
0:00
/1861
Facts
- Australian senator Fatima Payman, who had backed a parliamentary motion recognizing Palestine earlier this week, quit the ruling Labor Party on Thursday.1
- The 29-year-old from West Australia said she was 'deeply torn' between acting with 'a sense of urgency and moral clarity' and alleged pressure to conform to the party line.2
- Last week, Payman broke with the Labor Convention by declaring she was 'not elected as a token representative of diversity' and was suspended for crossing the floor.3
- Payman is the first Labor lawmaker to call Israel's actions in Gaza a genocide, reportedly frustrating the party-led pro-Israel government.4
- Elected in 2022 for a six-year term, Payman said she will remain an independent member of parliament, adding she isn't thinking of collaborating with the Muslim Vote group 'per se.'2
- Since her vote and her public stance on Israel, Payman claims to have received death threats and hostile emails and faced antisemitism allegations.5
Sources: 1BBC News, 2Guardian, 3Abc, 4World Socialist Web Site and 5The Sydney Morning Herald.
Narratives
- Narrative A, as provided by The Sydney Morning Herald. Payman's decision to cross the floor on the issue of Palestinian statehood, even at the risk of expulsion from her party, is a commendable act of integrity. Unlike others who may prioritize party solidarity, she followed her conscience, believing deeply in the need to recognize Palestinian statehood. This rare display of political courage and adherence to personal principles should be applauded.
- Narrative B, as provided by Australianjewishnews. Payman's stance is dangerous and needs to be condemned. She has undermined the Labor Party's longstanding commitment to a negotiated two-state solution. Besides jeopardizing party solidarity, she has ignored the complexities of Palestinian governance. In any case, Australian foreign policy isn't determined in the Senate. Payman's stance risks turning her into a martyr.